House and Senate file identical testing/accountability bills

Date Posted: 8/05/2025 | Author: Tricia Cave
On Monday, House Public Education Chairman Brad Buckley (R–Salado) filed House Bill (HB) 8, his standardized testing and accountability bill. Soon after, Sen. Paul Bettencourt (R–Houston) filed Senate Bill (SB) 8, the identical Senate version.
In recent days, state leaders have continued to use the rhetoric of “eliminating the STAAR test.” Based on conversations with educators and parents alike, it seems unlikely either group would consider the filed versions of HB 8/SB 8 a fulfillment of that promise, except in name only, but what would the bills do?
As drafted, the bills would:
- Go into effect in the 2027-28 school year, with the current STAAR test fully in place until then.
- Make through-year testing mandatory in grades 3-8 and optional in high school as an add-on to end-of-course exams (EOCs).
- Not eliminate any subjects currently being tested at any grade level.
- Give the commissioner of education significantly more authority over statewide testing and accountability. However, it would place new time constraints on the commissioner regarding notification to districts regarding cut scores.
- Substantially curtails districts’ ability to challenge the commissioner on matters of accountability, including rankings and sanctions.
- Direct the Texas Education Agency (TEA) to create beginning- and middle-of-year tests (BOYs and MOYs), as well as establish a list of non-agency developed tests, such as MAP, that could be used to meet the BOY and MOY requirements. The non-agency BOY and MOY could be nationally norm-referenced tests. The end-of-year test (EOY) would be a more STAAR-like, agency-developed test.
Although the bill does specify that 85% percent of students should be able to complete the tests in 60 to 90 minutes, depending on grade level and whether the test is a BOY/MOY test or an EOY test, it contains no new limit on the total amount of time available to take a test and no indication that multiple subjects could or should be tested on the same day. There is also no new limit on the number of instructional days that can be devoted to administration of state tests. Together, this means that while individual tests would likely be shorter, the number of days devoted to state testing could increase by as much as 300%. This would potentially be offset in part by an attempt to limit benchmark testing, especially in grades 3-8.
With the Democrats currently breaking quorum out of state, the House is limited in what actions it can take on this or any other legislation. However, if Gov. Greg Abbott (R) continues to call more special sessions, as he is likely to do, Buckley and Bettencourt can refile these bills and seek to move them once a quorum is present to do so.
ATPE members are the experts on Texas public education, which is why we strongly encourage you to use ATPE’s Advocacy Central to let your state leaders know what you think of HB 8/SB 8 and what you hope to see out of testing and accountability reform.
CONVERSATION
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

08/27/2025
From The Texas Tribune: House Democrats’ frustration with STAAR bill highlights divide over how new test should look
Democrats say recent changes to the bill give too much power to the TEA and fall short of meaningfully easing the pressures of standardized testing.

08/26/2025
House passes HB 8, its assessment and accountability bill
Five amendments were adopted before House members advanced the bill to the Senate on an 82-56 vote.

08/22/2025
Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: Aug. 22, 2025
The House Public Education Committee has advanced the House’s STAAR redesign bill, and the Ten Commandments law has been temporarily blocked in 11 districts.
When state testing was initiated several decades ago the purpose was to ensure kids who graduated from high school could read, write, and do basic math - all necessary skills for life. The tests now are a far cry from the original intent, and it seems to have become more about money than the kids’ learning. The current tests have zero to do with basic skills. This became more apparent with the introduction of AI grading. We live in a great state, so it is unfortunate that our education system, which affects the future of every child, family, community, entire state, and nation has become a glaring area of weakness and compromise. I pray daily that someone with common sense and a loud voice that can’t be ignored will become a major contributor to what happens next. This issue should be about people, not politics. Decisions that affect people have proven historically to be the backbone of society and directly determine the difference between mediocrity and greatness.
I (fortunately) don''t teach a tested subject, but the tests still affect my classes. I lose teaching time to all these tests and benchmarks, and most of my classes are mixed grade levels, so I get hit twice when half the class is gone one day and the other half is out two days later. And, let''s face it, tested subjects teach to the test, rather than teach to the subject. In my classes, I should not have to teach student to extrapolate, interpolate, or think critically; however, I have to undo years of teaching to the test in order to teach students how to learn and apply what they already know to help themselves understand new concepts. Really, the only accurate information the STAAR tests provide is (1) how good students are at taking tests, and (2) what kind of day they are having on test day. Classroom teachers have a better understanding of what their students know or don''t know. For the free response questions that have been added to the STAARs, AI is useless for grading. Therefore schools should never be limited on their ability to challenge the grading, especially if AI continues to be utilized. College Board spends millions of dollars to have thousands of teachers spend a week or more grading AP exam FRQs to ensure accurate scores. It kills me when a responder obviously knows the answer and understands the concept, but in their haste/stress/exhaustion leave out a key term (or an acceptable equivalent) that''s required to be in the response and I have to deny them the point. The millions wasted on STAAR testing are better spent on helping teachers equip their classrooms to provide students a high-quality education rather than us having beg, borrow or steal, dig into our own pockets for needed supplies and equipment, or do without.
Please stop all state testing. It creates even more unnecessary anxiety for my kids and they are already dealing with so much as it is. These tests are a detriment to their mental health and teach them grades matter. No, grades so not matter. Effort matters. Care matters. Integrity matters. These are the characteristics I want my son and daughter to know that are important and not the pass/ fail they receive after hours and hours of after school effort and Saturday mornings only to be told his efforts didn’t matter. He “failed”. He spiraled into tears. His in-class assessments matter- his relationship with his peers and teacher matter; and, his skill building matters. He performs As and Bs in those areas. These are what matter.
Stop the bs and let these kids stop testing you don’t care about our kids you just care about your pocket